Show Review: The Head and the Heart is warm and inviting at Arizona Financial Theatre

Tuesday night at Arizona Financial Theatre saw The Head and The Heart bring their Aperture Tour to downtown Phoenix, filling the room with the kind of warmth and connection that has defined their career.

The evening began with Tyler Ballgame, whose relaxed stage presence and warm songwriting pulled the audience in from the very first notes. His set felt conversational and approachable, marked by melodies that carried a sincerity perfectly suited to open the night. 

Following was John Vincent III, who brought a deep emotional weight to the stage. Known for his blend of folk-inspired melodies and raw lyricism, his performance was one that filled the theater with both stillness and release. Gentle acoustic moments hushed the crowd, while bigger, soaring choruses drew cheers and swaying bodies from front to back. Phoenix was fortunate to host him on his final night supporting the tour, and the audience gave him a warm sendoff.

By the time The Head and The Heart stepped into the spotlight, the room was alive with anticipation. The band wasted no time diving into a set that mixed longtime fan favorites with songs from Aperture. Tracks from their early catalog lit up the theater as the crowd sang along word for word, while the newer material held its own, proving how seamlessly it fits into their story.

The group’s trademark harmonies filled the space, weaving voices together in a way that feels both effortless and deeply intentional. What stood out most was the atmosphere: one of genuine joy and connection. The band carried themselves with the ease of seasoned performers, but the delivery still felt fresh, as though they were discovering the songs alongside the audience.

The night closed on a high note, with The Head and The Heart showing why their music continues to resonate more than a decade in. Their set balanced familiarity with growth, reminding Phoenix that the band’s evolution hasn’t dulled their impact — it’s only sharpened it.